1870 Harbor Blvd. #104
Costa Mesa, CA 92627
It's just an embarrassment of riches regarding the restaurant scene in Costa Mesa. Whenever I hear of a restaurant that would be right up my alley, it's likely opening up in Costa Mesa. Harper Barbecue, Ospi, Matty's Patty's, Verde, and more have made it onto my restaurant wishlist in the last few months. It's another newish spot that brought us to this restaurant-rich town this Sunday: Prince Street Pizza.
It seemed like Prince Street was never going to open. They had papered-over windows that announced they were coming to town for what seemed like years, but they finally opened their doors in July of last year at the much-maligned Triangle Square at the end of the 55 Freeway. On their opening day, 500 people lined up waiting to try their pizza.
I tried Prince Street Pizza in the Arts District area of LA almost two years ago. They started in New York City in 2012 and have expanded rapidly, with many Southern California locations and outposts in Toronto, Chicago, Miami, and Las Vegas. PSP is most known for its Sicilian-style pizzas, which are square and have an airy, almost breadlike crust. They also have thin-crusted Neapolitan pizza, a more conventional round form with which most people are more comfortable.
We arrived at noon, found parking in the dimly lit parking structure that is one of Triangle Square's trademarks, and went to the Newport Boulevard side at street level to get to PSP. We met a small line of three people waiting to order, and a few more waiting for their pizzas. Like all Prince Street Pizza locations, their storefronts are small, with no seating, and only a tiny bar where you can stand and eat your pizza, if you are so inclined. We got ours to go.
Ordering is done as you stand in line and pick your desired slices from behind the glass case. You do have the option of ordering a whole pizza, but PSP has always kind of felt like a pizza by the slice spot, which New York is famous for, and it also allows you to have some variety as to the kinds of pizza you can experience on a single visit. After selecting your pizza, it's taken to the oven for a final reheating and boxed up for you. We took ours home, and here's how it turned out for us.
We got a variety of slices to try, with Katie picking two and me picking the other two. Of these four, I enjoyed the Meat Lover's ($6.50) the most, not surprisingly. It comes with pepperoni, bacon bits, sausage, garlic, mozzarella, and a marinara base. People online claim that their marinara is too sweet, and it might be, but with the savoriness of the meats, it balances out. The silver medal goes to the Naughty Pie ($6.50), with a lot going on. Spicy vodka sauce, mozzarella, ricotta, pepperoni, and Zab's Hot Honey drizzle on top. I'm not usually a ricotta person, but with the slight spiciness of this and the pepperoni, I could handle it. I wish the honey had been used with a heavier hand, as the slice we got only had minimal honey.
The Sunset Square ($6.25) takes third place with its fresh and shredded mozzarella, pecorino romano, garlic, and sweet marinara sauce. The marinara was front and center, and indeed, too sweet. The slice was not balanced, and I grew tired of it after a few bites. Bringing up the rear was the Four Cheese ($6.25). I'm sure you can guess what the four cheeses were. That's right, fresh and shredded mozzarella, pecorino romano, and ricotta. There was too much ricotta, and this really needed a textural element, as it was very soft and rather bland. Not my jam at all. I'll let Katie have all of this next time.
Even though I was not a big fan of the last slice of pizza, I still enjoyed my visit to Prince Street Pizza. I'm not as in love with it as I was when I first visited back in 2023. At that time, I was unaware of Detroit-style pizza, a distant cousin of the Sicilian slices I had above, and the Michigan version is superior. I've also had some delicious pizza in the last two years, as excellent pizza places are popping up all over OC: B + C Pizza, Brooklyn City Pizza, Gibroni's, Truly Pizza, Lunitas, and Terra Mia, to name a few of my faves. PSP is still good, and I wish they were around when I used to frequent the bars in this area early in this century. I would have loved to come here for a slice after a night at Goat Hill Tavern. I'll be back to Prince Street Pizza, but for now, I need to do a lot of good eating in Costa Mesa.
Out of five ice cream scoopers (because the Prince Street Subway stop in NYC is not only where you would go for pizza, but it's also the stop for the Museum of Ice Cream), five being best to zero being worst, Prince Street Pizza gets 3 ice cream scoopers.
For more information about Prince Street Pizza, head to their website by clicking here:https://princestreetpizza.com/