H.H. Cotton's
201 Avenida Del Mar
San Clemente, CA 92672
When the temps start climbing into the triple digits, we look for any excuse to head to the beach cities for relief. As our first summer heat wave was searing into South OC, we had plans with our great friends Tom and Daniele to meet up, catch up on all of their big news, and, of course, have dinner out somewhere. Since we are food bloggers, or in Tom's case, a recovering food blogger, it's always a spirited discussion on where we will eat. They must have liked my suggestion of going towards the coast and trying H.H. Cotton's in San Clemente.
The twenty-degree temperature change was very noticeable once we arrived at this seaside paradise. I had not been in this bustling area of San Clemente in quite a long while. It immediately reminded me of Manhattan Beach but on a smaller scale. We were not the only ones in OC with the great idea of beating the heat inland and making a beeline for the coast. There are numerous restaurant options in this area of Del Mar; Nick's, Avila's El Ranchito, Beach Fire, and The Cellar, all packed on this Friday evening.
We had wisely made dinner reservations at H.H. Cotton's beforehand, so we only had to wait about five minutes after our arrival time of 7:30. We were seated deep inside the deceptively large restaurant, where the air conditioning seemed to be working the best. H.H. Cotton's had a real Jimmy's Famous American Tavern feel, with reclaimed wood throughout the space, a rowdy bar near the front door, and a darkened dining room.
One thing that is certain from dining here is that they are proud to be part of the San Clemente community. Not only do they have the names of San Clemente streets proudly displayed inside their booths and a large city map projected across the back wall of the restaurant, but this place is named after one of the two founders of this beautiful city, H.H. Cotton. He's Hamilton H. Cotton, to be precise, and he led a very colorful life, which included being the builder of his self-named estate, which we all know better as the Western White House, which not only was the home to President Nixon but also hosted FDR during his trips to the west coast.
The restaurant H. H. Cotton's is a joint effort by four local families. Their vision for their restaurant is to provide a family-friendly atmosphere, a place where locals come to celebrate milestones and others come to partake in the packed bar while watching local sports on one of the five TVs scattered throughout the restaurant. Like their Chef Jason Gamble, the menu draws inspiration from many places he's lived, including New Orleans, Hawaii, and California's Central Coast. Intrigued, we made our selections, and while we waited, we listened non-stop to our good friend Daniele's ongoing stories that we had definitely heard before since she had posted them all on her Facebook wall since the last time we had seen her. Here are my thoughts on the food we had this evening.
We were supposed to have two appetizers this evening, but our server only brought these Thai BBQ Wings and Drums ($14), so the poke would have to wait until our next visit. I'm usually partial to the spicier buffalo variety of wings, but this sweeter Thai sauce was nice for a change. The wings were very meaty, with tender, not overdone chicken underneath. The sauce was not too sticky, which made these very easy to eat with your hands.
Daniele had heard that it was National Fried Chicken Day on this particular Friday, so she wanted to get in the mood by trying out the Fried Chicken and Waffles ($21). She raved about this plate. She loved the fried chicken, which she called nearly perfect. The waffle was also good, and she loved this plate's sweet and savory feel. We finally got a respite from listening to her drone on and on about things while she ate this. The silence did us some good. The portion size did not warrant a price over twenty dollars, but that's my opinion.
Katie did not know it was fried chicken day but unwittingly participated by getting this Bird's the Word Chicken Sandwich ($14). I actually tried this, and it was a delicious chicken sandwich. You can get this either grilled or fried, and it comes with arugula, tomato, caramelized onion, and the unusual curry aioli. The bun was nice and soft, the chicken tender and the curry aioli added a good flavor boost to this sandwich. Katie chose the side salad with her sandwich instead of the fries. It was a basic but fresh side salad.
Tom finally broke the chicken juggernaut we had going here at H. H. Cotton's when he ordered this BBQ Spare Rib Plate ($18). This came with five pork ribs on a cutting board, coleslaw, half an ear of corn, and a cheddar biscuit. Let's start with the ribs. They were dry and challenging, and they needed the sauce they came out with to make them go down easier. I did not get a report on the corn, biscuit, or coleslaw, but Tom did finish them, which is a good sign.
When I saw the description of the Chili Verde ($17) on the menu here, I veered toward it, thanks in part to the inclusion of cheesy grits. I have been craving them since Lillie's Q closed almost two years ago. Including the grits, this was a chili verde with a southern slant. Also included in this was some shredded pork shank, salsa verde, cotija cheese, pickled onion, and, of course, those grits. This plate was good but a little disjointed. The pork was delicious, but not enough in here, and it was too small of pieces. The grits were done well, but the salsa and cotija cheese felt out of place here. About three-fourths of my way through this, I found the corn tortillas that came with this as they hid alongside the bottom of this rather large bowl. I don't know why they needed such a large bowl with the portion size that this came out with.
This meal taught us this evening that they do chicken rather well at H.H. Cotton's, but the other proteins fell flat. Tom and I would get something else next time, as I have my eye on one of their four burgers. I understand the higher price points at beach area restaurants, but they could have offered more significant portions, especially with my and Daniele's meals. Service was definitely spotty, to say the least. As mentioned, our server just plain forgot about our poke appetizer. Refilling or taking drink orders was not too quick, leaving us to fend for ourselves for long periods, especially when it came time to pay the check. Beach casual is to be expected, though, and luckily, we were not in that much of a rush since we were catching up. Even with these few hiccups, we would return and give them another try if we were in the area and wanted an opportunity to cool down during one of our summer heatwaves.
Out of five memoirs (because the Western White House, which H.H. Cotton had built is where Richard Nixon came to write his memoirs after his presidency ended), five being best to zero being worst, H.H. Cotton's gets 3 memoirs.
For more information about H.H. Cotton's, head to their website here: https://www.hhcottons.com/