Superb Steak in San Clemente?

 Rare Society

226 Avenida Del Mar

San Clemente, CA 92672

Man, these birthdays roll around way too quickly these days. It feels like just a month ago when we celebrated my birthday at Bourbon Steak in Dana Point. That meal was one of the best I have had in a long time, and not only was the food great, but the service was first-rate. Very memorable. I wanted the same thing for this birthday, so I picked another restaurant that has gotten lots of great press, Rare Society in San Clemente. 

Rare Society burst onto the San Clemente dining scene in May 2023. It is the brainchild of Chef and Restaurateur Brad Wise, who has five restaurant concepts up and running, most of which are in the San Diego area. Rare Society is his breakout hit, with six locations operating or opening soon. Be on the lookout for one in Las Vegas, poised to open sometime this year. It is across the street from the Durango Casino and Resort, about fifteen minutes west of the Vegas Strip, depending on traffic.

Back to the Rare Society in San Clemente. This restaurant was the hottest in OC for the first six months of its operation. Reservations were booked months in advance, and I made my reservation two months early for my June birthday. I recently checked for tables, and they have reservations for most nights. However, Saturdays appear to be their busiest night by a mile. If you eat here on a Saturday, plan ahead at least a few weeks in advance and place your reservation for your desired dining time. 

This is Chef Brad's homage to the vintage steakhouses of a bygone era, which evoke the specialness of upscale dining. Each of the Rare Society locations includes an on-premises dry ager filled with cuts of beef prominently displayed near the hostess stand and a wood-fired grill that utilizes American red oak to cook these cuts. The bar area is the focal point of this two-story restaurant, with stunning circular lighting hovering above the bar to the top of the second-level ceiling. Even though it's close to the ocean, you'll have to crane your neck to glimpse the Pacific. 

I was hoping that the food at Rare Society would be enough to make up for the lack of ocean views. The menu here has plenty of options, leading off with chilled seafood and a wide array of starters, and then you get to the star of the show, the proteins. They offer six steak options ranging between $52 to $91, along with pork, seafood, and a fried chicken option. Also of note, and quite popular from what I've seen online, are their two boards featuring a selection of chef cuts. These did not work for us, as Katie is one of those who likes her steak way too cooked for my tastes. Next time I'll have to bring someone else. Ha! Ten sides are available, which are served family-style. So, now that you know what's going on here, let's see how my birthday dinner was. 

Salads are listed under the starter portion of the menu, so we took the subtle cue to start our meal with those. Katie selected the Iceberg Wedge ($18), while I had my usual Caesar ($19). Of the two, I liked the iceberg version better, but barely. This quarter of iceberg lettuce was topped with plenty of bacon, grape tomatoes, red onion, and Danish blue cheese and drizzled with balsamic. Even though this did not have a dressing other than the balsamic to tie it together, it was one of the best versions of a wedge I have had. The bacon was crisp, the onions and blue cheese added a nice flavor punch, and the balsamic provided its usual flavor profile of sweet and tart in equal parts. Very well-balanced, and I was grateful for each forkful that Katie allowed me to have. I did not even have to throw out the birthday guilt to get more bites. She's the best. 

The Caesar was not to be dismissed either. As described on the menu, it includes a lot of pecorino, but under all that cheese, there is some romaine, fried anchovy, and lemon. The cheese is present but does not overpower, as it's light and almost melts in your mouth. The romaine was fresh, and the fried anchovy added a nice textural element. I'm a big dressing guy, but these salads did not need to be doused with dressing to be among some of the best we've had in recent memory. 

Our server highly recommended the Parker House Rolls ($15), so we ordered them while waiting for our main course. They come five to an order and come out scaldingly hot on a cast iron skillet. They are topped with truffle butter and herbs. These were everything that you want when eating Parker House rolls, soft, slightly sweet, and a cloudlike texture when bitten into. I would have liked the truffle butter to be served on the side, as it pooled around the top of the rolls and could be more evenly spread if served on the side.  

Chef Brad has ties to the Central California coast, and Santa Maria tri-tip is king in that area. It's no wonder that his menu features this Snake River Farms Wagyu Tri-Tip ($53), and it came out so well. This 10-ounce meat plate came sliced from the kitchen, allowing for easy eating. The tri-tip is known for its rich, beefy flavor, and this one did not disappoint. It was incredibly tender and lean. It was cooked perfectly medium, the way that Katie had requested. Our server suggested that their Santa Maria Salsa ($5) be paired with this, but it didn't need it. The salsa was watery, with no big flavor bump. 

I've always been a ribeye guy, and that held true this evening when I got the Cedar River Prime Bullseye Ribeye ($68) at Rare Society. This sixteen-ounce steak glistened on the plate before cutting. I liked the seasoning on the outside of the steak, and most bites were very satisfying. I know ribeye steaks include a lot of marbling, but this one had too much fat in the center. I felt a little cheated. I tried the Bearnaise Sauce ($5), which was way better than the salsa. It was rich and creamy and went well with the steak. 

Sides are always a must at a steakhouse, so we tried two. The better of the two was the Potato Au Gratin ($28). This version of this classic side was laden with black truffle and a truffle mornay sauce. It was very rich, as you'd expect, and it was lava-hot when it hit our table. If you'd like to skip the richness, the whipped potatoes might be more your scene. The Truffled Cream Spinach ($14) was a big letdown. As you can see from the picture above, the consistency was more like soup. The spinach was drowning in the sauce and did not cling to the spinach. I almost wanted to ask for a straw to eat this. This was very disappointing.  

The only thing more disappointing than the spinach was this Butter Cake ($15). I sing the praises of Buttercake wherever I go. It's easily my favorite dessert, and I've had many good ones, but this was not one of those. This was served with sour cream ice cream on top, which melted over the cake. The sour cream ice cream really hijacked this dessert. It's all I could taste, and I was not a fan. The cake portion was soggy and, again, overwhelmed by the sour cream taste. If you've never had butter cake before and want to try this one, just know that this is a unique version and might not be for you. It definitely was not for me, but it was comped for my birthday, which was very nice. 

Pun intended, but the dessert left a real sour taste in my mouth towards Rare Society. But, while writing this review, I softened my opinion of this restaurant. Things started out strong with the salads and Katie's tri-tip, but maybe I just got a lousy ribeye with too much fat in the middle. I did have some delicious bites, so maybe my steak was a fluke. The potato side was nicely done, but the creamed spinach was not one of my favorites. The butter cake was brutal and would be a hard pass on future Rare Society visits. There's enough on this menu that I'd visit again and try other things like their blue crab dip, steak boards, New York strip steak, and the pork tomahawk. As is true in most steakhouses, the service here was exemplary. Our server and food runners met our every need during our stay. Was this birthday meal as good as last year's at Bourbon Steak? No, but that dinner was also over a hundred dollars more, which makes Rare Society more approachable to most of us. 

Out of five footballs (because San Clemente was once the home of Pop Warner, a successful college football coach, and he is memorialized in the youth football league that bears his name), five being best to zero being worst, Rare Society gets 3.5 footballs. 

For more information about Rare Society, head to their website by clicking here: https://raresociety.com/