Lucy in the Sky With Pizza

 Sgt. Pepperoni's Pizza

26601 Aliso Creek Road, Suite D

Aliso Viejo, CA 92656

Whether you know it or not, we are living through OC's pizza renaissance right now. People used to lament that no excellent pizzas were available in Orange County. That has changed with the additions of some of my favorite spots to get a slice. Gibroni's, Terra Mia, Folk's, Truly Pizza, Tony's Little Italy, and Brooklyn City, to name a few off the top of my head. 

I feel I had let Sgt. Pepperoni's slip by me. They have been in business since the mid-70s, and I had never visited until they recently reached out to me via Instagram and invited us to see what they were all about. Their original location on Bristol in Newport is still operating, but now they have added two other locations in Irvine and Aliso Viejo to spread their pizza vibes to a broader audience of OC pizza fanatics. 

Sgt. Pepperoni's was started by childhood friends nearly fifty years ago. Like many pizza places, they are very involved in the communities they serve. Supporting youth sports teams, donating and participating in community events, and raising funds for local charities. Their passion project is Julian's Lego Corner fundraiser every September. They urge their customers to donate Lego sets to the children of Choc Hospital, and they also donate a portion of the sales of the pizza of the month to this worthy cause. This proves once again just how generous the restaurant industry is with not only nurturing us through food but also making others' lives better. 

We arrived at the Aliso Viejo location of Sgt. Pepperoni's at 6pm on a recent Sunday. We were met with a bustling restaurant. I was immediately drawn to the glass pizza case near the register. It featured a dozen varieties of pizza by the slice and their famous pinwheels, pizza dough, which is filled with toppings and sliced to resemble the child's toy of the same name. I could barely stop myself from drooling on the glass as we headed to the register to order. 

The menu here is, of course, pizza, pizza-focused. By my count, they offer 14 custom pizza options and build-your-own, gluten-free, and vegan pizzas. They also provide the unique option of having your favorite two specialty pizzas on each half of your pizza, which is great for the indecisive, which we were. Apps, sandwiches, salads, family meals, and desserts round out the rest of the menu. We quickly grabbed a table and waited for our food. 

I've been trying to eat more salads as of late, and Katie was inspired by my produce-eating habits, so she opted to get one of her own as well. She selected the House Salad ($12.50) to start off with. This salad featured mixed greens with tomatoes, mozzarella, pepperoni, cucumbers, pepperoncini, and croutons with ranch dressing. This was a good-sized salad that could have easily fed two people. She felt 

I went with my old reliable when it comes to salads, the Caesar ($12.50). This was about as straightforward of a version of a Caesar as you could make. Chopped romaine, shredded parmesan cheese, and croutons were all there was to this salad. It was still good, especially with the freshness of the romaine and the delicious Caesar dressing. They could have added more parmesan to this, though.   

If Garlic Knots ($8.50) are on the menu, Katie must try them when eating out. This pizza dough is rolled into a ball, coated with garlic and butter, and then baked. I liked these but was partial to the bigger ones, as they were a little more doughy on the inside. The garlic and butter really came through, but I would have liked some of their excellent ranch dressing for dipping these. I'll ask for that next time we get these. 

As I mentioned before, Sgt. Pepperoni's allows you to have two supreme pizzas on each half of your pizza. Perfect for us, who like different things on our pizza. On our 18-inch Pizza ($34.50), we got half with the works and the other half with all the meats. The works included pepperoni, meatballs, sausage, bell pepper, onions, olives, mushrooms, and garlic. This was Katie's side, as I'm averse to olives of any kind. I had a piece that was not covered in olives, which was good. I liked that the crust was manageable and held up structurally when lifted. The onions and garlic added a nice flavor boost as well. Katie was happy with her pick. 

I was happy with my meat side as well. Bacon, pepperoni, sausage, and meatballs covered much of the surface area. Every bite I took included some meat, which is only sometimes the case for other pizza places. The pepperoni crisped up around the edges, and the sausage was nicely spiced. I was also surprised that this was less greasy than expected due to the meat quality they use here. Next time, I'd spend the extra $1.50 and opt for extra cheese to help balance the toppings-to-cheese ratio. My additional two pieces heated up nicely for lunch the next day, 

It's no wonder that Sgt. Pepperoni's has been in business for close to 50 years. They offer some solid pizzas, perfect for youth sports teams, whether winning or losing, celebrating birthdays or any other occasion, and even a night in just watching movies and making memories at home. There's no time that pizza is not a good choice for any meal, especially nowadays, when pizza is having its moment in the sun. 

For more information about Sgt. Pepperoni's, head to their website by clicking here: https://sgtpepps.com/ 

** We were provided this meal for free in exchange for an honest review of their service/food. No other compensation was received.