3325 East Imperial Highway
Brea, CA 92823
It was day two of birthday dinners for Katie, and this time it was my family's turn to spoil the birthday girl. As is her custom, Katie yields the restaurant selection to me. This is not due to my prowess in picking great restaurants. It's more about me choosing a spot that will satisfy her and my family. After many minutes of research online, I finally decided on Julep in Brea.
Julep burst onto the scene eight months ago and is situated in the old Jimmy's Famous Tavern spot on the corner of Valencia and Imperial Highway in the La Floresta Shopping Center, which is anchored by Whole Foods, Mendocino Farms, and Urban Plates. Julep comes to us from the Toast Restaurant Group, which runs Mimosas Brunch and Dinner in both Whittier and Anaheim Hills, Benediction in the City of Industry, and Toast, which boasts three locations in Downey, Whittier, and down the road in Brea.
This is the least brunch-centric of their concepts, even though they offer a brunch menu on weekends from 8am til 3. The lunch and dinner menus are the same, and all items on both are offered after 11am daily. Julep has plenty of options for you to consider when dining here. They offer 13 appetizers, along with soups and salads. Burgers, sandwiches, and pasta dishes are available, with 14 more significant entrees of steaks, seafood, and chicken dishes. Prices range between $12 to $25 for starters, and entrees will set you back anywhere between $14 to $55 for their filet mignon.
They take reservations through their Yelp page, but only for parties of four or fewer. For bigger parties, you are asked to phone the restaurant, which I did since we were a party of six, but after numerous calls spread over several days with no one answering the phone, I decided we'd chance it and just show up. We met at half past four on a Sunday, which is not precisely peak meal-eating time. After a wait of about five minutes, we were seated.
The dining area conveys a pleasant and relaxed vibe with its exposed dark wood beams on the ceiling, striped tiled flooring, and glass roll-up doors allowing plenty of natural light to permeate the restaurant. The space is still recognizable from when this was Jimmy's, but they have added their own touches like the dragonflies and empty bird cages adorning the walls and the whimsical art spread throughout the restaurant.
We started with two appetizers, the first of which was the Corn Fritters ($13). These yellow corn fritters resembled tater tots, with a crunchy outer shell and a cornbread mixture inside. They came with a maple bourbon sauce for dipping. I'm not a huge cornbread fan, but everyone else enjoyed these. I enjoyed the choice of the dipping sauce, which saved these for me.
The Ahi Tuna Tartare ($18) gets a lot of love online. This tuna tower uses cubed tuna mixed with a sesame dressing as its base and then is topped with an avocado mash. It comes with wonton chips for scooping. I liked this, but I only had a couple bites since it was split among six people. The tuna was fresh but could have been seasoned a bit more. I enjoyed the avocado on top, which stole the show for me with this plate.
This Fried Chicken ($20) wins the award for most photogenic dish of the evening. The chicken breast was fried nicely with a delightful crunch when bitten into. It was also surprisingly tender all the way through. It was served with a large spoonful of garlic pomme puree, which you might know better as garlic mashed potatoes. They were very buttery, but the promised garlic was very muted. The plate was rounded out by a Dijon mustard sauce that lined the bottom and served as a gravy over the fried chicken. An odd choice that worked well because the mustard was not too front and center. My mom and sister enjoyed Julep's take on this American classic.
The birthday girl Katie picked the Beef Stroganoff ($25) as her celebratory meal. I'm sure I have not mentioned it, but Julep is a cast iron skillet restaurant, meaning all their entrees are cooked in or finished in a cast iron skillet. I think this dish was just finished in the cast iron. This meal was made up of filet mignon, pappardelle, and the same Dijon mustard sauce that was used on the fried chicken. Katie liked this version of the comfort food classic. The noodles were cooked nicely, the steak was tender, and she appreciated the uniqueness of the mustard sauce. She scrapped this plate clean.
It's always entertaining to see what my dad will order when we go out to eat. He did not disappoint by getting this Cast Iron Trout ($21). This rather large piece of trout was cooked to where it was flaky, but it was a little too mild in the flavor department for my tastes. The garlic mashed potatoes, and the green bean baby friese citrus salad did an admirable job of livening things up.
My brother-in-law had heard good things about the Shrimp and Grits ($21) at Julep, so he tried them. This was another interesting interpretation of a dish we've all had. The garlic shrimp and grits were placed on top of four asparagus spears and some red wine demi glaze and then topped with fried onions. This was too busy. The red wine sauce seemed out of place, and the asparagus should have been situated to the side, along with the fried onion strings. The shrimp and the grits were good but were overwhelmed by the other components of this plate.
I usually avoid getting ribs and other barbecue items at non-barbecue restaurants, but for some reason, these Coca-Cola Beef Ribs ($25) piqued my interest enough to order them. They were decent and better than some I have had in actual barbecue spots in OC. Plenty of tender and flavorful meat on these one-and-a-half ribs, and the barbecue sauce added a tinge of sweetness to each bite. I usually like to apply my own barbecue sauce to my meat, but this sauce was pretty solid. The plate was rounded out by some coleslaw and french fries, both of which were satisfying.
I admit I did not have the highest hopes for a good meal when we entered Julep this early Sunday evening. I changed my tune when we had finished eating, though. The food here will not blow you away and make you want to immediately return, but the menu is varied enough that almost anyone can find something at Julep that they will like. The little twists they add sometimes miss the mark, but not enough to ruin your meal. The service this evening could best be described as slow. Our server had a bunch of tables to attend to while other servers walked around aimlessly, not doing too much or helping our server out. It's a young staff, so they may find their way. The price point here was more than fair for the portion sizes. Not to break my arm, patting myself on my back, but this was a pretty good spot that I picked for my family to celebrate Katie's birthday. Everyone left here happy.
Out of five horses (because the most well-known julep is the mint julep, famous for being served at the Kentucky Derby), five being best to zero being worst, Julep gets 3 horses.
For more information about Julep, head to their website by clicking here: https://www.julepbrea.com/