Family and Eating Is Everything at Tutto Famiglia

Tutto Famiglia

23766 Mercury Road

Lake Forest, CA  92630

It was time to cross off one of the restaurants on my wishlist for far too long. Since I live within five miles of Tutto Famiglia, it's surprising I haven't been here until now. I guess I've been busy eating at every other Italian spot around me, but I'm here to remedy that with my good friend Daren, who loves to eat just as much as I do. 

Tutto Famiglia was on my list because my good friend and fellow blogger Anita Lau reviewed it in the OC Register 15 years ago. Yes, it was a long time ago, but she's a tough cookie when judging restaurants, and she liked it well enough for it to land on my restaurant list. Tutto Famiglia has been around longer than that review, as they've been in business since 2006. Judging from the photos on their Yelp page, not a lot has changed in the nearly twenty years since they opened. 

Family-owned, this restaurant is a little off the beaten track, as the shopping center is surrounded on two sides by residential housing, butts up against the 5 Freeway on one of the other sides, and has a hidden entrance off of Lake Forest Drive, where the shopping center is obscured by some hotels. If you remember where the old Black Angus used to be, which is now Sammy's Original, they are located to the left of that building.

Now that you've found the place, it's time to check out Tutto Famiglia's menu. We ordered off the lunch menu, which they offer from 11 a.m. to 2 p.m. Tuesday through Friday. They are closed on Mondays and are only open for dinner on weekends. The menu includes appetizers, pastas, baked dishes, pizzas, entrees, and two sandwiches. Only a handful of the entrees eclipse the $20 price point. It's a good-sized menu, but Daren and I were laser-focused and made our minds up rather quickly on what to order.  

Right after being seated, we were presented with this Garlic Bread. It was toasted and came with a decent amount of garlic. It reminded me of the Lawry's garlic spread my mom used when I was a kid. We gobbled this up very quickly. 

You might never think pizza is a warm-up act, but Daren and I are big eaters, and we wanted something substantial before our entrees. This Pepperoni Pizza ($17) would fill that bill for us. I was expecting a more traditional Italian pizza, but this was topped with plenty of cheese, sauce, and enough pepperoni so you got some in almost every bite. The crust was slightly thicker than a New York-style pizza and had a pleasing chew. The cheese-to-sauce ratio was where I like it, as the cheese was the star and the sauce provided some solid background support. This came to our table volcano hot, but we pushed through, burning our mouths because we were both hungry. Delicious pizza for a restaurant that does not solely sell pizza. 

Daren has a real affinity for Manicotti ($14) and rooting for awful football teams. Since this is a restaurant blog, I won't get into his football teams, but he scarfed down this manicotti in record time. The rolled pasta was filled with ricotta and parmesan cheeses and herbs, and then was topped with a tomato-cream sauce. This heavy meal pleased Daren way more than watching his Cowboys play on Sundays. 

I was torn between the lasagna and the Pasta Salsiccia ($15). This penne pasta dish had plenty of sliced sausage and a garlic-tomato sauce. The menu claimed the sauce would be spicy, but it was mild. I added some red pepper flakes and parmesan cheese to wake it up a bit. The pasta was cooked al dente, and the sausage tasted great. This was not earth-shattering, but a good, comforting, solid pasta dish.  

Tutto Famiglia is an excellent neighborhood Italian restaurant. They have been churning out these dishes for nearly twenty years, and that's the reason why they continue to be a favorite with locals; they are consistent, and they offer their food at a very fair price. They also have an extensive menu, so people can switch things up by getting something different every time they visit, thus not tiring them of ordering the same thing each time they eat here. It's comforting Italian food, not flashy or straight from Italy, which resonates with many people. 

Out of five airplanes (because the company that employs the most people in Lake Forest is Panasonic Avionics, which sells and installs in-flight entertainment and communications to airlines worldwide), five being best to zero being worst, Tutto Famiglia gets 3 airplanes. 

For more information about Tutto Famiglia, head to their website by clicking here: https://www.tuttofamiglia.com/